Quantum-sensor models: what Kshana models, and what it does not
Kshana is a PNT-resilience (PNT: positioning, navigation and timing) simulator with quantum-sensor performance models. It is not a first-principles quantum-physics simulator. This page states exactly what that means so the "quantum" framing cannot be mistaken for more than it is.
What IS modelled#
Each quantum (and classical) sensor is an error model driven by published noise-budget parameters:
- Clocks — white-frequency and random-walk-frequency PSDs (power spectral densities),
a flicker (1/f) Allan floor, and linear drift, sourced from datasheets and papers: the
CSAC (chip-scale atomic clock) Microchip SA.45s; the strontium optical-lattice clock of
Origlia et al. (arXiv:1503.08457), a space-oriented goal; and the six
ClockClassdefaults (CSAC; USO, ultra-stable oscillator; DSAC, Deep Space Atomic Clock; TCXO, temperature-compensated crystal oscillator; OCXO, oven-controlled crystal oscillator; RAFS, rubidium atomic frequency standard), each citing one source. The Allan deviation these produce is validated against the standard noise-type slopes (seeVALIDATION.md). One optical-clock curve is real: the measured ⁸⁸Sr tweezer-clock Allan deviation of Norcia et al. (Science 2019) is reproduced by the noise fit, a VALIDATED row inVERIFICATION-MATRIX.md; the holdover figures built on the optical class stay MODELLED. - Inertial sensors — in the
inertialand hybrid packs, a single-axis (1-DOF, one degree of freedom) accelerometer/gyro error budget: velocity random walk, angular random walk, acceleration random walk, and an Allan bias-instability floor. Thegnss-insandhybrid-ukfkinds instead run the three-axis strapdown mechanisation insrc/inertial/(quaternion attitude, north-east-down navigation equations, a deterministic IMU error model). - The quantum scenario kinds —
quantum-trade,quantum-time-transfer,quantum-anomaly-detect,quantum-gnss-free-navandhybrid-ukf— are built from these error models and are MODELLED;quantum-time-transfer,quantum-anomaly-detectandquantum-gnss-free-navalso report a representativeness record with the gaps to flight. - The engine is neutral: "quantum" and "classical" are the same code path with different coefficients. The contrast in the figures of merit comes entirely from the input noise parameters, each traceable to a cited source.
What is NOT modelled#
For the clock and time-transfer sensors, none of the underlying quantum physics is simulated — only the net Allan contribution, supplied as a coefficient. For the cold-atom accelerometer a first-principles layer now exists (see below); the remaining systematics are still coefficient-level or unmodelled:
the atom-interferometer Mach–Zehnder phase (
Φ = k_eff·a·T²), quantum projection / shot noise (σ_Φ = 1/(C·√N)), interferometer contrast decay, cycle time, and the vibration-coupling transfer function (|H(ω)| = (4/ω²)sin²(ωT/2), white-PSD varianceσ_Φ² = k_eff²·S_a·T³/3) are now modelled from first principles for the CAI (cold-atom interferometer) accelerometer (src/inertial/quantum_imu.rs), deriving the white-acceleration PSDq_vathe classical model consumes, together with the fringe-ambiguity dynamic range (a_max = π/(k_eff·T²)) — seeQUANTUM.md;the Coriolis systematic (
coriolis_phase/coriolis_accel_bias, the2·v⊥·Ωcross-coupling) and the AC-Stark (AC: alternating-current) / light-shift systematic (ac_stark_phase, which cancels under a symmetric two-photon detuning) are now modelled and unit-tested insrc/inertial/quantum_imu.rs;three further CAI error terms are now modelled as library functions in
src/inertial/cai_error_terms.rs(0.36; MODELLED; not yet reachable from a scenario kind):- Raman laser-phase noise: the sensitivity-function weighting of Cheinet et al.
(2008), Eq. 8, with the white-phase closed form
σ_Φ² = (π/2)²·S_φ⁰/τ_R(Eq. 18 at one cycle) and a numeric route for any phase-noise spectrum, plus the laser frequency noise that the retro-reflection delayt_d = 2L/cdoes not cancel (Le Gouët et al. 2007, Eqs. 9 to 11); - wavefront curvature (pure defocus only): the bias
δg = σ_v²/Rof a thermal cloud on a beam of curvature radiusR, and its reduction when only atoms inside a detection radius are counted (after Louchet-Chauvet et al. 2011 and Schkolnik et al. 2015); higher-order aberrations are not modelled; - fringe-ambiguity resolution: the probability of a wrong fringe index,
erfc(π/(√2·s)), for a classical-accelerometer aid (Lautier et al. 2014) and for two interrogation times (after Bonnin et al. 2018), with the inverse that gives the largest classical noise for a stated failure probability.
Each closed form is checked against an independent numerical route (frequency-domain quadrature, or a Monte Carlo over atoms or shots) and its limiting cases. The one published number reproduced is Cheinet et al.'s white-phase-noise level: −111 dB·rad²/Hz at
τ_R= 20 µs gives about 1 mrad per shot (0.99 mrad; the paper derives that level with its Eq. 17, flicker plus white). None of this is a measurement of any instrument;- Raman laser-phase noise: the sensitivity-function weighting of Cheinet et al.
(2008), Eq. 8, with the white-phase closed form
still not modelled: higher-order wavefront aberrations, the phase noise of a specific laser system, and clock-side first-principles physics;
the quantum-versus-classical
inertialpack is single-axis; the three-axis strapdown path runs only ingnss-insandhybrid-ukf(see the IMU, inertial measurement unit, note in the README andVALIDATION.md).
Completing the quantum-physics layer (reaching the CAI error terms from a scenario kind,
higher-order wavefront aberrations and clock-side first-principles physics) is the
remaining P2 work in
ROADMAP.md.
Ground-lab vs. flight-qualified figures#
Parameter tables mix maturity levels; treat them accordingly:
| Sensor | Source figure | Maturity |
|---|---|---|
| CSAC (e.g. SA.45s) | datasheet σ_y(1 s) ≈ 3e-10 | deployed commercial part (radiation-tolerant space variants exist) |
| Strontium optical-lattice clock | σ_y(1 s) goal ≈ 1e-15 (arXiv:1503.08457) | ground-lab — Kshana knows of no published in-orbit performance for one |
| Cold-atom accelerometer | published lab Allan figures | ground-lab / sounding-rocket |
Optical-clock figures in Kshana are space goals on ground hardware. No flown optical clock exists; the README and result provenance say so explicitly.
Benchmark: ACES/PHARAO on the ISS (operational since April 2025)#
The ESA (European Space Agency) ACES/PHARAO payload (ACES: Atomic Clock Ensemble in Space; PHARAO: Projet d'Horloge Atomique par Refroidissement d'Atomes en Orbite) — a laser-cooled caesium clock plus an active hydrogen maser, operating on the ISS (International Space Station) since April 2025 — is the current operational on-orbit clock-stability benchmark (target fractional stability of order 1e-16 after a few days of integration). Kshana's optical-clock model represents a more aggressive ground-lab goal than ACES's flown caesium/maser performance; when comparing Kshana's optical numbers to "what has actually flown", ACES/PHARAO is the honest reference point, and it is a microwave/maser system, not an optical-lattice clock.
The exact ACES in-orbit performance figures should be cited from ESA's published results as they are released; the point here is the maturity gap, not a specific number — Kshana's optical figures are goals, not flown performance.
See also#
VALIDATION.md— per-parametervalidated/not modeledlabels.GLOSSARY.md— figure-of-merit (FoM) definitions and every abbreviation.INTEGRITY.md— what the Integrity and Security FoMs are and are not.QUANTUM.md— the first-principles cold-atom accelerometer.